One of the most magical things about cooler weather is that fashion transforms into wonderful, baggy, shapeless warmth blankets that are acceptable to wear in public. I don't know why this is okay, but I fully embrace it. The key to making your blanket scarves and drapey ponchos more public appropriate is to pair them with structured pieces like a long button up or classic boots...or both.
Poncho, Loft (similar from Wet Seal).
Top, J.Crew (similar from Factory).
Leggings, Yummie by Heather Thompson (similar from same).
Boots, Stuart Weitzman (similar from Amazon).
Bag, Alexander Wang (similar from Last Call).
Necklace, Bauble Bar.
Glasses, Miu Miu via Ditto.